From Association member, Ret. NYPD Deputy Commissioner Bob Ganley that appeared in the NY Daily News July 14, 2025

Medicare Advantage switch cheats NYC retirees

Roller coasters and senior citizens are rarely a good match. But a hair-raising ride seems to have ended well for some 250,000 retired New York City municipal workers. After New York’s highest court ruled against retirees — saying that the promise made to them for more than 50 years that they would be entitled to traditional Medicare and a city-paid supplemental plan — was not explicitly written into any contract or city document, Mayor Adams announced he would not be forcing retirees into a Medicare Advantage plan.

This is welcome news, for now, and retirees’ anxiety should be allayed, at least temporarily. Because the next mayor could renege on that promise and again try to force seniors into Medicare Advantage. In addition to Adams’ pledge, Andrew Cuomo, Curtis Sliwa, and Jim Walden have promised to protect retirees; but Zohran Mamdani has not.

It is important to remember how we got here. And perhaps that history will be useful to Mamdani and get him to stand with the retirees.

Four years ago today, July 14, 2021, then-Mayor Bill de Blasio announced he was going to make retirees pay for the supplemental insurance policy that the city had funded for nearly half a century. Why? Because he used the Health Stabilization fund as a piggy bank, took a billion dollars and didn’t pay it back.

De Blasio figured he could get half of it by taking retiree benefits. Instead of allowing senior citizens and disabled first-responders choose the plan that was right for them — and the vast majority have chosen traditional Medicare — de Blasio forced every one of them into an inferior Medicare Advantage plan run by a for-profit insurance company. He said it would “save” the city more than $500 million a year, but in truth, the city wasn’t going to save a dime: that money was going back into the fund he took it from with no oversight.

A coalition of retirees from every walk of life — former firefighters, police officers, teachers, lawyers — banded together and took on City Hall.

They took a job working for the city and were repeatedly told by city officials, “You will not get rich, but when you retire, you will have a pension and high-quality, city-funded health care in the form of Medicare and supplemental insurance.” These promised benefits are deferred compensation for working — and possibly risking your life for — the city.

Now that the city was trying to take them away. After winning seven legal battles to keep what they earned, the highest court in the state decided against us. We lost an important battle. Generation after generation of city workers heard the promise. It was repeated in recruiting sessions, one-on-one meetings with HR people, and in the annual Summary Program Description (SPD) booklets handed out to every city worker. The evidence of this promise — including unrebutted testimony from hundreds of former city officials and retirees — was overwhelming.

But according to the Court of Appeals, that wasn’t enough. Those didn’t count as explicit promises that could bind the city. The court concluded the precise wording of the promise did not satisfy the technical requirements of a doctrine known as promissory estoppel. All that means is the city did not have to keep its word.

This disappointing legal conclusion does not change the fundamental facts found by the lower courts: (1) city officials recruited and retained retirees by telling us that we would be provided traditional Medicare plus a Medicare supplemental plan; (2) retirees have detrimentally relied on that promise; and (3) denying retirees this insurance now would imperil our lives, as many of our doctors will not accept Medicare Advantage.

The Court of Appeals decision is important for two reasons. First, city and union leaders will have to take greater care in spelling out benefits for future retirees. Whether in bargaining agreements or SPDs, people will remember that words — and their absence — have consequences. And second, while Adams’ decision allows us to breathe a sigh of relief, retiree health benefits should not be subject to politics or expediency; they need to be codified in law.

Now is time for the City Council to step up. It needs to codify retirees’ right to traditional Medicare plus supplemental insurance. There is a bill pending — Intro 1096 sponsored by Councilmember Chris Marte — that would protect retirees. But Speaker Adrienne Adams has refused to allow it to come to the floor for a vote.

Mayor Adams and Speaker Adams can show their leadership by getting councilmembers to take a stand supporting seniors and disabled first responders: Enact 1096 and help retirees get off this dangerous roller coaster.

 A special event took place on Thursday, June 19th, at Nino's Restaurant for the Staten Island luncheon. Along with the regular attendees at the monthly event, Retirees Association President Bob Valentino, along with Treasurer Tony Lomanto, Advisor Fred Ametrano and member Tony Magliano were present to make a special donation to Tunnel to Towers from the Retirees Association honoring Honorary Member and retired past President of the NYPD DEA, Paul DiGiacomo. Also present was US Congresswoman Nicole Malliotakis and United States Secret Agent Anthony Lacorazza, son of Retired Lieutenant Joseph Lacorazza, Retired Chief John Kavanagh, and former Spokesperson for the NYC Transit Police, Al O'Leary, and many others. .

At the affair, T 2 T CEO Frank Siller spoke to the group. He thanked us for the $8000 donation and spoke about what the organization does to help first responders and military families in times of need.  US Congresswoman Nicole Malliotakis spoke of the current situations with law enforcement and the need to improve conditions for the officers in this country.

NYPD Transit Bureau Chief Joseph Gulotta attended and spoke to the group. He spoke of respect for the Transit officers who patrolled the subway system in those early days of single man patrol and with no radios. He even had a recent PD academy class entirely assigned to the Transit Bureau doing 2-man subway patrol on the lines from one end to the other to learn what it is like. These days, being assigned to the Transit Bureau can be described as a “detail.”

Making a trip up north from Baton Rouge LA for the luncheon was Lifetime Member Fabian Blache and his grandson, Landon. Fabian spoke of the great reputation of the Transit Police Department and the camaraderie our retirees have shown over the years and how the Association has undertaken the steps to keep it going.

Paul DiGiacomo spoke of his feelings about the Transit Police and the Retirees Association over the years and how we always kept the name of his father alive. His father, Paul Sr., was a PO in District 34 for many years. Paul has been very generous to the association with many donations to our affairs and, in retirement, made a very generous personal donation.

 
Jim Nuciforo, Fred Ametrano, Tom Lupia, Mike Korn                                     Paul DiGiacomo, Fred Ametrano, Jim Nuciforo                   Tony Lomanto, Bob Valentino, Paul DiGiacomo, Frank Siller, Fred Ametrano

 L-R Chief Gulotta, Tony Magliano, US Congresswoman Malliotakis, Bob Valentino, Tom Lupia, Tony Lomanto
 
L-R Chief Gulotta, Tony Lomanto, US Congresswoman Malliotakis, T 2 T CEO Frank Siller, Bob Valentino, Fred Ametrano, and Paul DiGiacomo with the $8000 donation check

 US Congresswoman Nicole Malliotakis speaking to the group with Tony Magliano listening intently

                         
Transit Bureau Chief Joseph Gulotta                           Paul DiGiacomo thanking the Retirees Assn.       Chief Gulotta spoke highly of the Transit Police Department officers

 Ret. Sgt. Fabian Blache flew up from Baton Rouge for this special occasion  

We received a phone call from Det. Katherine Abreu at the NYPD Transit Bureau Personnel Unit . She has received recent phone calls from several pre-merge Transit Police officers regarding the renewal of their ID cards. They reported trying to email the Bureau with information required but those emails never went through.

The problem was in the email address of Det. Abreu. It is TBHQPERSONNEL@NYPD.org

What was happening is when the email address was typed out on their computer, they misspelled the word "personnel" bY spelling it personel, using only one 'n.'

Please note that Det. Abreu will be on vacation from July 21 to August 1, returning to work on August 5th.

If this affected you, please re-send your required items to the correct address TBHQPERSONNEL@NYPD.org

We thank Recording Secretary Bob Forrester with able assistance from his wife, Fran, for this report.

The meeting was called to order by President Valentino with the Pledge of Allegiance and the reading of names of recent fellow officers who passed away since our last meeting. It was also mentioned that our Editor, Frank Crisa, is in the hospital undergoing treatment for severe anemia requiring blood and other transfusions. It is requested that no phone calls be made to Frank as extended talking on his part leads to severe coughing spells. Please keep Frank in your prayers for a full recovery.

Bob mentioned the names of several members whose birthdays are in June, and we all wished them well. We then broke to enjoy the many delicious Verdi’s buffet refreshments being served.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported the current standing of our financials which are in good order and the fact we have so far received over $7000 in donations alone. For the donations to Tunnel 2 Towers, to date we have received $6100, which is amazing, and we thank everyone who was able to make a donation. The full amount will be given to Tunnel 2 Towers on June 19th at the Staten Island luncheon in the name of Ret. NYPD DEA President Paul DiGiacomo. Paul has always been very generous to the Retirees Association over the years, and he always says he always wanted to be a Transit Officer like his father, Paul Sr.

Tony brought out the fact that there are 16 members who still have not sent in their dues for 2025 and they risk being dropped as members. Several correspondences, unfortunately, have not resulted in any positive results.

President Valentino thanked member Mike Lavelle, who donated a Transit Police banner that he just came across in his belongings. It was on display at the meeting.

Bob also mentioned the two Florida Reunions taking place in Florida in August and September this year. If you are interested in either, please contact the reunion hosts.

Tony Lomanto talked about the ongoing court cases between the Organization of Public Service Retirees and the City of New York. We have still not heard any decision by the NYS Court of Appeals that took place on May 15th. We mentioned the fact that we did not like some of the judges’ comments that were made during the hearing. When such a decision is made and released, we will post the results on our website and send out an email to our members. As to the Co-Pay case, no date has been set for a court hearing. We urge our members to donate to the Organization to protect our rightful benefits. Go to Home | NYC Public Retirees for instructions.

Legislative Director Tony Piazza gave a talk on the current legislation for the Variable Supplements Fund (VSF) There are bills in the Senate (S7528) and Assembly bill (A8267) that are currently “in committee” and awaiting release to the floor for a vote. We urge all members to contact their representatives to support these bills.

Lodge 317 President Robin Becker, present at the meeting, asked any FOP member concerned who paid their dues for 2025 and have not received their membership cards to please be patient, It takes time from when dues are sent to State and National, to get the cards. She also mentioned receiving a message from Rabbi Berkowitz, who is currently travelling, offering his best wishes to everyone to have a wonderful summer.

Bob Valentino reported that there still are tickets available for the Annual Bowling League Dinner Dance taking place on June 6th at Verdis of Westbury. If interested, contact Bob at 516-809-0010.

2nd VP Vin DiMaio spoke of the recent LEOSA Reform Bill that passed in the US House of Representatives. The bill expands the provisions of HR218 allowing changes to magazine capacity and locations where you can carry that are currently not allowed such as Federal locations, schools, churches, etc. It needs a compromising bill from the Senate to pass and forwarded to President Trump for signing. It didn’t make it last year and if nothing this year, it will be re-introduced in 2026.

Member Joe Asti, who was formerly a Firearms Instructor and is now an instructor with Safety Quest Ltd. offering firearms qualifications for HR218, brought out some very interesting incidents involving retirees and their weapons when going through the course. Some had a weapon that did not function properly, or they were not up to date on proper weapon handling. He stressed the point of taking care of any weapon you carry as you want to make sure it works if ever you need it. Joe also mentioned that current rules regarding your pistol carry permit have changed. Unless you have HR218 in effect when it comes time to renew your permit, you will be required to undergo the 16-hour training class and a firearms qualification. You will also have to have your retiree ID card in effect.

President Valentino mentioned that the Association is in the process of checking out a Knights of Columbus Hall located in Marine Park Brooklyn as a possible site for a meeting. We will be looking at it later in June when we return from the Staten Island luncheon. If acceptable, we will use it for our October meeting. The membership will be notified of this by email and website posting. Bob further urged the members to check out our website frequently to see any changes and notifications.

The meeting of over 70 members was then adjourned.

Here's an article about yesterday's NY State Court of Appeals arguments: Click on this link to read what took place yesterday, May 15th

Battle over Big Apple retiree health benefits goes to NY high court | Courthouse News Service

The May membership meeting took place at Verdi's of Whitestone and we had a good turnout.

President Valentino started the meeting with the Pledge of Allegiance followed by Treasurer Tony Lomanto reading the list of 8 members and fellow officers who passed away since our last meeting.

Pres. Valentino mentioned the Bowling Dinner-Dance that will take place on Friday, June 6th at Verdi's of Westbury. More details will be posted when finalized. He also mentioned the possibility of having a new meeting location at a Knights of Columbus Hall in Marine Park Brooklyn. When it is finalized, we will post it here and notify our members by email. This new location would be held in October.

Bobby then spoke of the FOP Police Memorial held on May 3rd with several board members and association members present to honor the 73 law enforcement officers who passed away in the past few years, Please see the event information and photos below.

Bob then spoke of the Honor Flight to Washington DC held on May 3rd for a large number of veterans, including our members Fred Ametrano, Arthur Grix, and James Kirk. Upon their arrival home, they were warmly greeted by a large group of Association members formed by President Valentino, along with friends and family members. He further mentioned the fact that so many retired officers from Transit who are on social media forums like Facebook, fail to join our organization.

Treasurer Lomanto spoke of the financials of the association and how many donations were sent by our members. All donations, no matter the size, are greatly appreciated and help with the ever rising cost of running the association. With more and more members reaching Lifetime Membership status each year, the dues coming in are reduced.

Tony also mentioned that the Medicare Part B reimbursement was sent out by the City on April 10th and to check your account that your monthly pension payment is sent. For those receiving a paper check, you should be receiving it later this month. For those impacted by the extra Medicare deduction known as IRMAA, the form is available on the link below. It is based on your adjusted gross income from 2 years ago.

He further discussed the latest in the health care coverage cases being heard and mentioned that on May 15th, the Organization of Public Service Retirees will have a hearing in the Appeals Court on the "Bentkowski Case', also known as the "Nuclear Case" where the City is threatening having only a medical plan for retirees, the Medicare Advantage Plan. The GHI Co-Pays are still in effect but no date has been set by the court for appeals. We strongly urge our members to make a donation to their cause which is trying to save the health benefit coverage we are entitled to. Donations can be made at www.nycretirees.org

On the VSF issue, we finally have bills in Albany to correct the unfair prior legislation that denied the fund for many reitrees before July 1, 1987.
Senate Bill #S7528 and Assembly Bill #A8267 have been introduced and are now in committee. We ask that you write or call your representatives to back these bills.

Tony reminded the members of the 2025 Florida Reunions, the first of which is the Original Florida Reunion being held August 3rd to the 7th and, in September, the Black Patch Reunion will take place September 11th to the 15th. Details are on the Meeting and Events page of this website.

1st VP Deo Fasolino spoke to the members saying how much Hank Melchiona thanked and appreciated all who attended the 55th Memorial Mass held on February 28th for his brother, Michael. Deo also spoke of the photos that appeared on Facebook taken at Mike's funeral, the largest turnout of law enforcement for a fellow officer killed in the line of duty at the time. The photos were erroneously attributed to someone else when, in fact, they were taken by the late Ret. PO William Martin.

2nd VP Ron DiMaio spoke of personal protection coverage plans that are available for those who conceal carry and have HR 218 permits. Plans are available through CCW Safe found at CCWSAFE.COM or the FOP Legal Defense Plan at FOP.NET for which you must be a member. They are not insurance plans which must comply with various state laws to be classified as insurance. One of the main differences between the two are that with CCW Safe, no expenses are paid first then reimbursed as is the FOP plan.

Member Ret. Sgt. Michelle Kemp spoke if the organization she belongs to which is POPPA. It started about 30 years ago when a large number of police and service member suicides were taking place. POPPA helps the person or family members dealing with a person in need of help to prevent a suicide. Please check the Meeting and Events page for an invitation to a ZOOM Meeting on May 21st that may afford helpful advice for anyone in need of their services. Michelle mentioned that it was Joe McGarry who inspired her to join the organization.

FOP Lodge 317 President Robin Becker talked about the National Police Memorial Week taking place in Washington DC the week of May 11th to the 17th. Robin will be going with a few other lodge members to the event.

The meeting was then adjourned.

HONOR FLIGHT PHOTOS

  

                         Jim Kirk, Fred Ametrano Arthur Grix                Bobby Valentino and the Greeters                                       Jim Kirk

Fred Ametrano and his daughter

 
NYS Fraternal Order of Police Headquarters

 
Inscriptions on the Memorial Wall

 
Joe McGarry's Memorial brick in front of The Memorial Wall

R- Ed Cassar (who lived across the street from Joe) next to Joe's daughter, Colleen Kobayashi, Joe's son, Brendan, and her husband, George on far right, along with their children and adopted brother 


Mike Lavelle, Ed Cassar, Gene Sullivan, George Colgan  

 
                 Mary Ansbro being escorted by her family to the Memorial Wall

 
Brendan and his sister Colleen and their family    

Hicksville Fire Department Tower Ladder with Flag

  
        NYPD & Nassau PD Helicopters flyover as Taps is being played

    
Tony Lomanto & Bob Valentino

Thanks to Lou Hollander keystonecop1@verizon.net for sending this information.

2024 Medicare Part B reimbursements was issued during the third week of April 2025. Please check your bank account/statement
If you don’t have EFT or direct deposit, you will receive a check in the mail in June.

Learn more about Medicare Part B Reimbursement at the Office of Labor relations web site. https://www.nyc.gov/site/olr/health/retiree/health-retiree-medb-irmaa.page

IRMAA 2024 Reimbursement

Medicare-eligible retirees and their Medicare-eligible dependents can submit an IRMAA application if they paid above the standard amount of $164.90 per month ($1,978.80 annually). If you did not pay more than the standard amount then you are not eligible for IRMAA.

IRMAA 2023 annual reimbursements were issued during the third week of October 2024.

Learn More about IRMAA Medicare Part B Reimbursement at the Office of Labor relations web site above.

IRMAA Medicare Part B Reimbursement Application (for 2023, 2022 & 2021) available on the website.

The IRMAA Medicare Part B Reimbursement Application for 2024 is now available here . IRMAA INFORMATION INSTRUCTION FORM

Important - Please do not submit your application more than once. Submitting your application multiple times or ways will only delay the processing time. You will receive a confirmation letter in the mail 4-6 weeks from the date you submit your application. Payment will be issued in October 2024.

From Ret. PO Chip Hayes chip1440@lawyer.com

I have attached this for all our members who served in Combat. This is also for all Vets.  Just open the link and you will see the information.

Vietnam War veterans will receive a lapel pin emblazoned with lasting symbolism from a grateful nation, according to Nancy O’Donnell of Schaghticoke, a spokeswoman for the Gerald B.H. Solomon Saratoga National Cemetery Support Group.
 
Veterans can apply for the medals online by going to the Division of Military and Naval Affairs website at  www.dmna.ny.gov/awards .

Applicants can use an online form to request the medals, or they can print out and mail in an application form.

Applicants must be a resident of New York state now, or a New York state resident when they served in Iraq or Afghanistan.

Applicants must provide a digital or paper copy of their Department of Defense Form 214 certificate of release or discharge from active duty as proof of military service in the two theaters of action.

Family members and other designated individuals can apply on behalf of a veteran. The medal can also be awarded posthumously.

ANNUAL BLUE MASS FOR FALLEN POLICE OFFICERS

On Sunday, April 27th, 2025, the Knights of Columbus in Lynbrook, NY, will host a Blue Mass and Communion Breakfast, with the Mass at 9:30 AM at Our Lady of Lourdes in Malverne, NY, followed by the breakfast at the Knights of Columbus hall.

Mass Location: Our Lady of Lourdes, 65 Wright Ave, Malverne, NY

Breakfast Location: Knights of Columbus, 78 Hempstead Ave, Lynbrook, NY

Contact for Information & Tickets: Linda Skirlos 516-287-4634

Ticket Prices: $15 for a single ticket, $150 for a full table (10 people)

This year they will be honoring
PO Cecil Frank Sledge, 69 Pct, EOW - 01/26/1980 and PO Anthony Dwyer MTS Pct, EOW - 10/17/1989

The first meeting of the NYCRTPOA for 2025 was  held on Wednesday, March 5th at Verdi's.

President Bob Valentino called the meeting to order at 12:00 pm with the Pledge of Allegiance to The Flag, followed by a moment of silence for the 12 departed fellow officers we were notified of since the December meeting, for all law enforcement recently killed in the line of duty, for family members who passed, for all law enforcement and our armed forces serving in harm's way and for those on the Sick List.

Bob thanked everyone who attended the Mass and 55th anniversary of the death of Michael Melchiona, the first uniformed Transit Police Officer killed in the line of duty..  It was a very good turnout.The full story and photos can be viewed on our website.

We celebrated five birthdays in March to these members present at the meeting: Ronnie DiMaio, Fran Forrester, Joe Sacrestano, Arnie Fisher and Joe DiDonato, with many happy and healthy birthdays to come.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported the Association is doing well financially since we received many donations from October 1, 2024 to March 1, 2025. Please see the list of donations in the next issue of Beyond The Line. 

Tony Lomanto reported that he and Editor Frank Crisa completed the next issue of our newsletter, and it is at the printer. It  should be in the mail by mid March.  It will consist of 56 pages of pictures, articles and letters.  The magazine costs approximately $8,000 for printing and mailing.  Bob Valentino thanked Tony and Frank for all their hard work. This is another reason why donations are so needed.
 
Tony reported that 63 members still did not pay their dues.  Please update your email or address if there are any changes.

Kenny Chiulli and his wife Maria were thanked for helping to get new members at recent gatherings by passing out application envelopes.

If you are SOC, CEA or LBA, please see the Website for information regarding the Part D drug plan that was recently enacted. It was as a result of complying with the Inflation Reduction Act passed by President Biden while in office..

Executive Secretary Tom Greer reported that there will be no baseball tickets available this year. The price went up to $265 per ticket but he hopes that maybe next year will be better.

Legislative Director Tony Piazza reported that our VSF bill has not come up yet, and it is an uphill battle. A letter was sent to the NYC Actuary.  There are only about 300 members who would be affected.

Regarding Health Care - the Court Case is coming up soon in May.  Please continue to send donations to the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees who work very hard for us.  Please go to their Website for information - www.nycretirees.org.

The Bowling Dinner will be held on June 6th.  Flyers will go out soon.

The next meeting will be held on Wednesday, May 7th at Verdi's in Whitestone.

The meeting adjourned at 1:40 pm.

Robert Forrester, Recording Secretary (with his able assistant and wife, Fran)

On Friday, February 28^th, a Memorial Mass was held at St. Sebastian Church in Queens to honor the 55^th anniversary of the death of Patrolman Michael Melchiona, killed in the line of duty at the 50^th Street & Broadway station. The mass, and many more previous ones, has been organized by his brother and Transit Retired P.O. Henry Melchiona to honor his brother, the first uniformed Transit Police Officer killed in the line of duty. 

The mass was attended by many members and friends of the Melchiona family, Transit Retirees Association members, a contingent of officers from the NYPD including many from District 1, the NYPD Honor Guard along with the Department’s War Pipe Band, and Joseph Gulotta, Chief of the Transit Bureau with other NYPD Chiefs. Also in attendance was Paul DiGiacomo, Jr. retired President of the NYPD DEA, Arthur Egner, NYPD PBA Treasurer, and Hank’s nephew, Brian McMurray, who beautifully performed “Amazing Grace” and “Ave Maria” on the cello during the mass.

Msgr. Romano, one of our Association chaplains gave a very nice talk about the uniqueness of our department. He talked about how we keep the camaraderie going and will always remember our fallen brothers and sisters, something other law enforcement departments he said found strange.

Hank Melchiona then spoke to the gathering, and without any cursing, too! He told the story of the incident that resulted in his brother’s death and how the 3 NYPD officers nearby came to the rescue to stop the culprit from any further deaths or injuries. Seeing so many young officers in the group, he told them to be proud of what you are and cautioned them to be alert and protect themselves in any incident incurred. When asked how long he will continue the memorial masses for Michael, he said: “Until I die.”

Stephanie Diller, wife of the late NYPD Det. Jonathan Diller who was also killed in the line of duty on March 25, 2024, was also present at the mass.

The photos can be viewed in this PDF of photos

Our thanks to Ret. Lt. Mark Lipira for forwarding this information to us

MEDICARE PART D

Recently the Superior Officers Council (Lieutenants and above) was forced by the stipulations contained in the Biden administration’s Inflation Reduction Act to abandon the commercial prescription drug plan they had provided to our Medicare covered members for decades.

The Inflation Reduction Act has forced the SOC to now convert the commercial prescription drug plan into a traditional Medicare Part D prescription drug plan. If the SOC did not comply with the dictates of the Inflation Reduction Act, our members would be liable to individual financial penalties that would be cumulative with each passing year.

This penalty would be financially crushing to our members. In essence we were pushed into a corner by federal legislation to convert the Drug coverage offered to our Medicare covered members. Many of our Medicare enrolled members have been in direct communication with the SOC regarding issues/questions related to the logistical changes associated with this new Part D Drug Plan.

The LBA has established a dedicated phone number, 646-669-8484, to address/answer questions regarding this matter. When you call this number, you will be asked to leave your name and your return phone number. A member of the LBA staff will return your call by the end of the day. Jennara Cobb, the Prescription Plan Coordinator of the SOC, must be acknowledged for her tireless efforts in providing guidance and assistance to hundreds of our members during this shift in prescription coverage.

We received the membership form for NEW memberships only in BJ's Wholesale Club. This membership is effective February 3rd, 2025 and will expire January 31, 2026. The CODE is shown in the details.

Please DO NOT CALL before February 3rd as the code will not be activated before that date.

Information for existing members is located at the end of the page and there are savings shown.

Please check the BJ PDF for full details.

We mailed out the 2025 dues notices and cards to the PAID and NON-PAID members and have recently been experiencing problems with the Post Office.

Their envelopes were returned mostly for unknown address, moved, no forwarding, or forwarding expired.

It appears the Post Office is getting strict with exact address information. Many of our members live in condos, co-ops, or apartments and they have not given us their unit, apartment, or even a site number and as a result, the mail was returned.

We also have the following member's mail returned and we were unable to contact them either by email (no longer valid) or phone number on file (disconnected, no longer in use, etc.)

If you know any of these members and are able to contact them, please do so and have them contact us with their current address. Either call me at 516-526-7968 or alomanto@optonline.net

LYNN McDONNELL (wife of the late Ret. PO Tom McDonnell) last address in Palm Coast FL - no response to email and phone is NG

ANTHONY PASSIONE last address Lakewood NJ - phone NG, no email   Deceased / see Obituary page

ELENA ROUTLEDGE (wife of the late Ret. PO Kevin Routledge) last address Rockaway Park NY. phone NG, email sent - no reply

ROBERT FRIBERG last address Haverstraw NY phone NG, no email

NEAL MENSACK last address in Delray Beach FL email sent - rejected / mailbox full, phone NG

THOMAS KOEHLER  last address in Englewood FL - no email, phone NG

JAMES SCOTT last address  San Tan Valley AZ no email / phone NG

We ask that when you receive the dues notice application, please do not put it aside for another day, but to make out the check, complete the application and mail it back to us. Make note of any changes to address, phone, emails or applicable beneficiary so we can update our records. Some members still have not paid the dues for 2024 so we ask if this applies to you, please send in the 2024 dues with the 2025 dues to remain a member in good standing.

When we receive your dues, we will send out the membership cards and decals to you. Of course, mail will be crossing paths so if you receive a dues notice and have already sent in your dues, just disregard the application/dues envelope.

As always, we ask, if possible, to please send in a donation of any amount so we can continue to run this organization and keep the Transit Spirit alive. IF a donation of $20 or more is included, please indicate if you would like us to send you a challenge coin as our thanks.

Thank you.
Bob Valentino, President

The Annual Christmas and Holiday party was an astounding success. Over 90 people attended the affair during which three new members were inducted into the Transit Police Sports Hall of Fame, Certificate of Appreciation were awarded to six of our Executive Board members, and a special presentation poster and plaque was awarded to our Editor-in-Chief, Frank Crisa.

President Bob Valentino opened the meeting with the Pledge of Allegiance after the group sang "God Bless America."

Treasurer Tony Lomanto read off the names of the 12 Transit retirees who passed away since our last meeting in October. May they all Rest in Peace. We asked that they, their families and those members and family members on the Sick List, are kept in your thoughts and prayers along with all law enforcement officers injured or killed in the line of duty and our Armed Forces serving in harm's way.

Our Association Chaplain, Msgr. Robert Romano, arrived at the start of the party and gave a blessing to the group. Unfortunately, Msgr. Romano wasn't able to remain as he had a few more affairs to attend after ours.

President Valentino introduced the following board members with a Certificate of Appreciation for their work in the Association's never-ending help for the retirees: Tony Piazza, as Chairman of the Legislative Committee, his assistants John Rini and John Giangrasso, Recording Secretary Bob Forrester, along with his lovely wife and assistant, Fran, and finally Financial Secretary Gregg Stripp and Executive Secretary Tom Greer for their tiring work meeting our attending members at the door of all our meetings. All the recipients thanked the Association for being honored at this event.

The following members were inducted into the Transit Police Sports Hall of Fame and awarded plaques and a Hall of Fame jacket:
Tom Santino for Boxing, Anthony DeToma for Softball, and Henry 'Hank' Melchiona for Firearms. Tom Santino and Anthony DeToma thanked the Association for the honor of being inducted.

When Hank Melchiona spoke, he also thanked the Association for the honor and then brought up the event of his brother being killed in the line of duty. Hank remarked to what the feeling is like when losing a brother in such a tragic way and then mentioned Luca Scarangello, seated at one of the tables, who also went through such an event when his brother John was also killed in the line of duty.

The highlight of the party came when our Editor-in-Chief, Frank Crisa, was asked to come forward and presented to the members. President Valentino presented a plaque to Frank, acknowledging the years of work and dedication he has given to the members with his work on our great newsletter, 'Beyond the Line.' Treasurer Tony Lomanto then presented a special poster to Frank, showing him at work at his desk with the newsletter in progress. We have to thank our member, Ronnie Morales, living in Texas, with the artwork he did with the poster. His similar poster works started with one he designed for Lou Hollander, then another for Tony Lomanto that was given to him last year. We must give a special thanks to Lou Hollander for his ideas that were then incorporated into the posters.

Frank was totally surprised at the presentation and his wife, Carol, who at first wasn't preparing to attend, was there when we told her what we were planning to do. Frank was wondering what Tony Lomanto said to her earlier over the phone that prompted her to be there with him.

The party continued with great food and refreshments until the time when all good things must come to an end. We wished all a very Merry Christmas, Happy Hanukkah, and Happy Kwanzaa, and a healthy and Happy New Year to all.

Photos from the party can be viewed in this PDF LINK   

LATEST UPDATE WITH THE ORGANIZATION OF PUBLIC SERVICE RETIREES AGAINST THE CITY OF NEW YORK

The latest good news is that the City lost, for the 11th time, in their appeal to turn back the previous court's decision against the City forcing the Medicare retirees into a Medicare Advantage plan. The court ruled that Medicare Supplemental medical coverage being paid in full by the City that has been in effect for more than 50 years, must continue and the City cannot force any retiree into the MAP.

From Legislative Director Tony Piazza:

Another retiree court case from the NYS Court of Appeals ruled 7-0 in favor of the retirees against OLR (Office of Labor Relations, known as the Campion Case). The city must pay the entire cost of the health plan. Two more cases to fight in 2025, one being the co-pay. However, if the city council would pass Legislative Bill 1096, all would end. The bill provides that the City must offer Medicare-eligible City retirees and their Medicare-eligible dependents at least one Medigap plan with benefits equivalent to or better than those available to City retirees and their dependents as of December 31, 2021.

Several of the City Council members are in favor of the bill but the remaining members are still being persauded by the false information being spewed out by the MLC and in particular, DC37.

Photos from the 2024 NY Reunion can be viewed in this  PDF

Sorry it took so long to post them, but I had to get help from Lou Hollander to identify some of those present. Thanks, Lou.

For those members collecting Social Security, the cost of living increase starting in January, 2025 will be 2.5%. That amounts to an average of $48 a month. The annual deductible for Medicare Part B will increase by $17 in 2025 to $257, while the standard monthly premium for Medicare Part B will increase by $10.30 to $185, CMS announced.

Beginning January 1, 2025, people with Part D plans through traditional Medicare and Medicare Advantage plans with prescription drug coverage won't pay more than $2,000 * over the calendar year in out-of-pocket costs for their prescription medications.

The meeting began with President Valentino leading the membership with the Pledge of Allegiance to The Flag.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto then read the names of 5 Transit Police officers who passed away since our last meeting.  He then asked the members to remember them in your prayers and also remember their families, first responders and those in harm's way, those on the Sick List, and any family members who may have passed away. A moment of silence followed.

President Bob Valentino introduced our special guest, WW2 Veteran David Marshall who, a few days before, celebrated his 100th Birthday. Dave, who was a Corporal in the US Army 84th Infantry Division, landed on Omaha Beach in Normandy on D-Day and, later on, fought in the Battle of the Bulge. He was happy to announce that he "survived without a scratch."

Bob Valentino & Dave Marshall

He is happy to be in good health, goes to the gym and is looking forward to "a few more good years."  He was surprised with a beautiful birthday cake with sparkling candles.  After “Happy Birthday” was sung, Dave posed for pictures with the members. 

Fred Ametrano, Dave Marshall, Tony Lomanto, Bob Valentino


Dave Marshall and the Executive Board

Dave was accompanied to the meeting by his friends Cynthia Haledo and her father Henk Haledo. Dave first met Cynthia, who is a photographer with the Dutch Army, when he was at a D-Day Memorial a few years ago and they have been friends ever since. Cynthia and her father actually live in Arnhem, Netherlands, the site of the famous WWII Battle “Market Garden.” You may remember it from the movie, “A Bridge Too Far,”

Congratulations to Mike and Doris Lanning who became great grandparents to a beautiful baby girl named Violet on October 1st.

Bob then gave birthday wishes to several members whose birthdays are In October.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported that along with our Editor, Frank Crisa, the next issue of our newsletter, ‘Beyond the line,” will be out by the end of October. It is 52 pages filled with articles and many pictures.  He also mentioned that next year dues will be $40.00 and asked everyone to please pay their dues on time.  He also mentioned that any donations would be appreciated considering the rising costs of the association. We currently have approximately $10,000.00 in the checking account. Tony mentioned that we had 11 new members joining, though we did lose 27 members since January 1st. 

Executive Secretary Tom Greer and Financial Secretary Gregg Stripp were thanked for doing a great job greeting the members at the door and selling the 50/50 raffle tickets. Tom mentioned he is working on the 2025 Mets- Yankees Game and it will be announced when finalized.

First Vice President Deo Fasolino spoke about the passing of members Vinny Servedio and Jimmy Groark and how special they were. They were bot “legends” in the Transit Police Department.

Second Vice President Vinny DiMaio stressed how important it is to vote.  We endorsed our member, Mike Sapraicone for US Senate. Whatever choice you may have, please get out and vote.

Legislative Director Tony Piazza gave an update on the VSF bill and how the City fights it every time it comes up.  He also mentioned the current situation with the City’s health care litigations and encouraged the members to donate whatever amount we can to NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees who are doing a great job for us.  Their website is www.nycretirees.org.

Robin Becker, President of FOP Lodge 317 asked members to send in their 2025 dues by October 20^th. The next meeting of FOP Lodge 317will be on October 24^th at 12 Noon at the K of C in Hicksville. Check our website for full details.

Henry Melchiona, who made a very generous $1,000 donation at the meeting, invited members to a 10:30 am Mass on February 28, 2025, for the 55th Anniversary of his brother Michael's death. He has arranged to have 5 vans take members from his home in Ronkonkoma to St. Sebastian's Church in Woodside, Queens.

At the 50/50 raffle drawing, a few winners donated their prize back to the association. We also received more donations from several members at the end of the meeting. We thank each and every one who has made a donation.

President Valentino reminded the members of 2 dates to remember: 

November 19th NY Reunion at Antun's - $70.00 by check, $75 at the door,
December 11th Retirees Christmas & Holiday Party at Verdi's - $30.00 for members or guests.

The meeting adjourned at 1:40pm.

Recording Secretary Robert Forrester  (with able assistance from his wife, Fran)

Pres. Bob Valentino called the meeting to order at 12:00 pm with the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag followed by Emil Stucchio's Transit Police theme song -'Proud To Be A Transit Police Officer'.

Bob also said that the new meeting time of 11:30am works well with the member’s travelling times with traffic conditions.

Treas. Tony Lomanto reported since our last meeting we lost 15 fellow Transit Police Officers.  May they rest in peace. Please keep their families, our armed services and all the officers who work all day in your prayers along with family members who may have passed away.

Following lunch, the meeting resumed at 12:45 pm.  President Valentino mentioned the names of 4 members who will be celebrating their birthdays in September.

Rabbi Berkowitz gave a nice talk and congratulated Det. Paul Di Giacomo on his retirement. He also wished Rich Petito good health and spoke of his fond memories of the late Father DeAngelo.  He then spoke of the anniversary of 911 and how the public should be educated - morals and traditions must come back.

Pres. Bob Valentino, along with Bob Ganley and Paul DiGiacomo, presented awards to the new recipients who were present at the meeting into the Retired Transit Police Officers Association Sports Hall of Fame.  They included Ralph Barrato (Softball),
Vito Buonsante (Softball), George Pisanti (Softball) and Nick Russo (Softball Manager). The fifth recipient, Lemuel Lockhart (Softball Manager), was not able to attend. The newly installed members thanked Bob and the Association for the honor and for hosting the event.

Bob Ganley spoke about the current healthcare situation. The City is appealing our new favorable ruling in Albany in November. So far, the $15 co-pays for Emblem Health will start in January unless the court decides on the issue entirely. He stressed what a good job the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees is doing for us and encouraged the members to donate what we can. Bob then took questions and announced that he is now on the board of the Organization and is available to answer any questions you may have in the future. Visit their website WWW.NYCRETIREES.ORG  

He also mentioned that Empire BlueCross BlueShield became Anthem Blue Cross and Blue Shield. The new ID cards were mailed to those having that coverage which led to much confusion.

According to the NYC Health Benefits website healthbenefitshome (nyc.gov) there is no change to your benefits coverage.

Ret. Det. Paul Di Giacomo spoke of his retirement after 42 years with the NYPD.  He recently joined the Tunnel 2 Towers Foundation and commented on what wonderful work they do. Paul is, and always was, a true friend of the Transit Police Retirees Association. His father, Paul Sr., retired after 20 years and worked in D-34 for many years.

Frank Crisa and Tony Lomanto reported they are working on the next issue of ‘Beyond the Line’ which will go out in early October.  Please send articles and pictures to Tony or Frank.  Original photos only, please. They will be scanned and returned to you.

Treas. Tony Lomanto gave a report on the financials of the organization and what some the current expenses of the organization. The 2 newsletters last year cost close to $12,000. The Death benefits paid out in 2023 amounted to $7800 and this year to date it is $8100. He reported that many current Regular membership members will be turning 75 in 2025 and will no longer be required to pay dues. That is a good reason to send in a donation to keep us going into the future. Unless sufficient revenue comes in through dues and donations, we may have to cut back on the death benefit to $200 or $250. We hope this never comes to pass.

Please make sure your home address and email addresses are current and check our website for latest news and announcements. It is www.beyondtheline-tpa.org  Tony reported that we regularly get email rejections to some of the email addresses we currently have in the database.

The NY Reunion will be held on Nov. 19th at Antun's, and The Black Patch Luncheon will be held on Sept. 28th at Verdi’s.  The
information can be found on the website.

FOP Lodge 317 President Robin Becker announced the next FOP Meeting will be held on October 24th at Noon at the Knights of Columbus in Hicksville. Details on our website

As always, we thank all our board members for their support and especially to Greg Stripp and Tom Greer for their great work at the door welcoming our members.

Bob Valentino thanked the members for a good turnout and the meeting was adjourned at 1:45pm. 

Fraternally,
Bob Forrester, Recording Secretary. (with able assistance of his wife, Fran)

On the "Chow Line" for a great buffet

                              
Ron DiMaio, Fred Ametrano, Bob Ganley, Paul DiGiacomo          Bob Forrester and Mike Lanning on the left

                              
                       All the members on the 'Chow Line'                L-R Paul DiGiacomo, Bob Ganley, Ralph Baratto, Bob Valentino
          

                                                            Paul DiGiacomo, Bob Ganley, Vito Buonsante, Bob Valentino  

 

Paul DiGiacomo, Bob Ganley, Nick Russo, Bob Valentino

              

                           Paul DiGiacomo, Bob Ganley, George Pisanti's son, George, George Pisanti, Bob Valentino

L-R   Sam Sapienza, Fred Ametrano, Mike Kilgannon, Mike Lanning, Bob Kent, Bob Valentino, John Kellett, Vito Buonsante, Bob Ganley, Gil Doremus, Ralph Baratto, George Mitchell, Nick Russo George Pisanti.

From Alan Berkowitz berky4@aol.com

COST OF LIVING ADJUSTMENT

A Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) is a permanent annual increase to your pension, based on the cost-of-living index and a formula set by State law. Once you are eligible, you automatically receive a COLA increase each September.
 

How COLA is Determined

This Year’s COLA Increase

The September 2024 COLA is 1.8 percent, for a maximum annual increase of $324, or $27 per month before taxes.
The increase you receive each September is added to your existing monthly COLA amount. You can view your benefit payment pay stub to see a breakdown of your pension payment, including your total monthly COLA amount, in your Retirement Online account.
• Sign in to Retirement Online.
• Click “View Pension Check” link.
• Select the date of the pension payment that you want to view.
You will also receive a notification of the net change in your monthly amount by mail at the end of September. It will show both your previous month’s and new monthly COLA amount, which represents the total accumulated amount for all the COLA increases you’ve received since you became eligible. Your 2024 COLA is the difference between Last Month and This Month.

When You’ll Be Eligible

Just about enough to fill a tank of gas.

Thanks to John Rini dad2020@optonline.net for sending this information from the Retired Sergeants Association

Update regarding the pending litigation of the $15 co-pay for the GHI/Empire BlueCross BlueShield Senior Care Plan

 Marianne says we are still discussing our options as to whether to appeal the co-pay case, but she will be talking at 7 am this morning on WBAI (and at the Friday night update tonight) about the co-pay case, Mayor Adams' statements at a Town Hall in Riverdale, and his office's subsequent statements that double down on the tired (and untrue) arguments that Medicare Advantage is superior to traditional Medicare and will save the City money. 

In addition, Marianne asks NYC voters to make sure we vote for candidates who support us, not by statements in their newsletters, but by supporting legislation to protect us.

Thanks to Alan Berkowitz berky4@aol.com for sending us these 2 great pieces of information.

First:

The 2024 Cost-of-Living Adjustment (COLA) for eligible retirees and beneficiaries is 1.8%.
If you are eligible to receive COLA, it will be reflected in your September 30, 2024 Pension Payment.
It amounts to $27 a month

Second:

The UFT withdraws support for Medicare Advantage Plan.

UFT President Michael Mulgrew sent a letter to the Municipal Labor Union Chairperson Harry Nespoli informing him that the UFT is no longer supporting the effort to implement the Medicare Advantage Plan with the City of New York.

The Organization of Public Service Retirees has come out with this Retiree Update:

Today, Sunday June 23rd, the United Federation of Teachers (UFT) announced to their members, retirees and the Press that he was withdrawing his support for Medicare Advantage. 

Here is our response:

We KNOW this is not over.  The Mayor has another week to file "leave for appeal" (ask permission to appeal) to the highest Court in the state.  We are still awaiting court dates for the first two cases - Campion - What does 12-126 mean?  and the Co Pay Case which was to stop the imposition of Copays. We are still fundraising for litigation, and our legislation is coming back!!
Stay tuned warriors! 
.

The full letter can be read HERE

With thanks to Recording Sec'ty Bob Forrester and his wife, Fran:

President Bob Valentino called the meeting to order at 12:15 pm with the Pledge of Allegiance to The Flag.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported we lost 5 fellow Transit Police Officers since our last meeting, along with Father D'Angelo from
The Shields of Long Island. We asked for prayers for them and their families and also for our Armed forces and recent law-enforcement officers who lost their lives in the performance of their duties along with all officers and family members on the Sick List.

Bob Valentino spoke of the 80th Anniversary of D-Day; all the men who fought, the sacrifices they made and for all who lost their lives in Normandy - truly the "Greatest Generation."

We had two guest speakers:

Association Chaplain Rabbi Berkowitz remembered Father D'Angelo as the perfect example of a member of the Clergy. He then reported on his recent visit to Israel with 25 members of the Clergy. He spoke of the horrors of October 7th and the 125 hostages still being held.  He spoke movingly about the rich history of Israel and its people.  Bob Valentino asked for prayers for all who suffered on October 7th.

President Valentino reported that the Executive Board unanimously voted to endorse member Mike Sapraicone who is running for US Senator against current Sen. Kirsten Gillebrand. Mike has worked for New Yorkers for over 20 years as a Transit ,then as an NYPD Police Officer and Detective. We feel he has a better knowledge of legislation that would affect law enforcement. Members were urged to vote for him.

Bob also mentioned that many members, several being present at the meeting, were celebrating their birthdays in the month of June. We all gave them a big Happy Birthday applause.

Former Deputy Police Commissioner Bob Ganley reported he received a call from Albany in the morning that the bills submitted for a vote to guarantee our health benefits were now being rejected in Albany by their not coming to the floor for a vote. He further mentioned that the City of NY, though not yet reported, may appeal the recent decision where they lost the case regarding co-pays and of any moving of retirees into a Medicare Advantage Plan from their current Medicare and GHI plans.

Bob Valentino reported that at the Sept. 4th meeting, 4 members will be inducted into the Sports Hall of Fame. It was decided that the September meeting will start at 11:30 AM to alleviate traffic problems for those members who travel far.

Information about the June 14th Bowling Dinner can be found on the Website on the Latest News page report of the May meeting.

Executive Sect’y Tom Greer reported he has sold all the Mets-Yankees baseball tickets and we thanked Tom for all his work with this event every year.

Tony Lomanto mentioned we were having a navigation problem with the Website which is being worked on and is now back in operation. Bob urged members to visit the Website at least once a week for up -to-date information.

Treas. Tony Lomanto reported we have $15,500.00 in checking and have $4,000.00 in donations. All our expenses have gone up.  On July 24th postage will be $.73 for first class.  In light of these, and other increasing costs, the 2025 dues will go from $30.00 to $40.00 per year.

Legislative Director Tony Piazza spoke of the City of New York and also the Variable Supplement Fund, noting that there are only about 300 members who would receive this benefit.

Tony thanked Greg Stripp (L) and Tom Greer (R) for taking care of the members at the door

Bob then thanked Tony Lomanto and Frank Crisa for their great work on the “Beyond the Line” magazine. Tony mentioned that he and Frank were already working on the next issue and if you have any photos or articles you would like to see in that issue, please send them to us. Unfortunately, newspaper articles are difficult to copy and publish.

Tony asked members to notify him if their address or email has changed.

After the 50/50 raffle, the meeting adjourned at 2:00 pm.

Respectfully submitted,
Fran and Bob Forrester

The Organization of Public Service Retirees www.nycretirees.org announced that the Appellate Court has ruled IN FAVOR of the organization in the appeal case started by the City of New York and the forcing of retirees into the Medicare Advantage Plan (MAP).

From the OPSR:

On March 21, 2024, we had oral arguments and today, May 21, we were given a unanimous decision.  We thank all of you for believing in us and our legal team.  Without all of you, we would never have gotten this far.  The Court said the City cannot take away our Medicare Supplement.

This is the exact decision,

"Accordingly, the judgment (denominated an order) of the Supreme Court, New York County (Lyle E. Frank, J.), entered September 19, 2023, which, in this hybrid proceeding-class action brought pursuant to CPLR article 78, granted the petition complaint to the extent of permanently enjoining the City respondents/defendants from eliminating petitioner/plaintiff retirees’ existing health insurance, automatically enrolling them in a new Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan, enforcing a June 30, 2023 deadline for retirees to opt out of the new plan, and implementing any other aspect of the City’s new retiree healthcare policy, should be affirmed, without costs."

You can read it here 

May 13, 2024                     FUNDRAISER FOR RET. SGT. RORY McGINN'S GRANDDAUGHTER

From Lou Hollander keystonecop1@verizon.net

CHARITY FUNDRAISER FOR RORY McGINN'S GRANDDAUGHTER LILLY

Lilly is the Granddaughter of Association member Ret. Sgt. Rory McGinn. Please help this precious 6 year old little girl Lilly and other children who have this unknown disease. See the letter below I received from Rory.

Louie, On June 8, 2024 my son in law Johan Fagerholt will be participating in the Orphaned Disease Center’s Million Dollar Bike Ride to benefit the TBC1D24 Foundation taking place in Philadelphia, PA.

On October 18, 2017 my wife Lillian and I welcomed our first Grandchild Lillian (aka Lilly) to the world. Lilly began having seizures at 3 months old. After multiple hospitalizations and specialist appointments Lilly was diagnosed with a rare genetic mutation. So rare it doesn’t have a name only a number, TBC1D24.

The mutation causes many medical issues including sensorineural hearing loss, drug resistant epilepsy, hypotonia and dystonia. In many cases those diagnosed do not thrive and pass within their first years of life.

Lilly is one of the lucky ones and although she lives every day with various symptoms she is a very happy girl who greets everyone with a smile! And she has two great parents, Bridget and Johan.

Donations to the TBC1D24 Million Dollar Bike Ride are matched by corporate sponsors and 100% of donations are awarded for research grants to help future kids.

Please go to Support Johan Fagerholt - 2024 Million Dollar Bike Ride | PledgeIt for Charities   Johan Fagerholt is riding that day.

Louie, I can’t thank you enough.
Rory

The Retirees Association donated $100 to help.

President Valentino started the meeting with the Pledge of Allegiance followed by Treasurer Tony Lomanto reading off the names of the 11 fellow officers who passed away since our last meeting in March. We asked that they and their family members be remembered in your prayers along with the law enforcement officers recently killed in the line of duty. We also ask that all our fellow officers and family members on the Sick List be remembered with your prayers and for our fellow law enforcement and Armed Forces serving in harm’s way.

After a delicious buffet meal, President Valentino said he was very happy with the number of members attending the meeting at this new location, Verdi's of Whitestone, and mentioned that we will be scouting a location in Brooklyn for a possible meeting location. One former Brooklyn location that held meetings was the Ben McChree Boat Club off the Belt Parkway. Unfortunately, they are no longer in business. We will inform our members where the June 5th meeting will take place.

Bob then sent birthday greetings to all our members whose birthdays are in May, including our editor, Frank Crisa. He further commented on the number of great comments he has received with our recent issue of “Beyond the Line” and how much that newsletter means to the membership. It is, truly, one of the ‘glues’ that holds us together.

Bob mentioned that he will be going for knee replacement surgery at the Manhattan Hospital for Special Surgery on May 22nd. He expects to be bowling again shortly thereafter.

Bob spoke of the Annual Bowling League Dinner Dance to be held on June 14th at Verdi’s of Westbury. The cost is $140.00 per couple.  Entertainment will be by the group "Desert Highway," the Eagles tribute band.  Contact Bob at leftybowler0601@gmail.com   

Executive Secretary Tom Greer informed us all 100 tickets for the Mets-Yankees Game on June 25th have been sold out. Tom will be texting the tickets to those who purchased them in a few days. Another job well-done, Tom, and thank you.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto thanked all the members who sent condolences, Mass, or sympathy cards to him after his brother passed away in March. He thanked all the members present for attending this meeting at the new location. We saw several members from The Bronx and Westchester County who couldn’t make the meetings on Long Island.

He then gave a hearty “Thank You!” to Frank Crisa for the work he did in putting together this last issue and how proud he is to be working with Frank. Any PAID member who has not received their copy, please contact Tony Lomanto at 516-526-7968 or alomanto@optonline.net 

Financially, we are doing well. We have 5 new members joining and the donations have been coming in as you can see in the last issue. We deeply appreciate them in view of ever-increasing costs for printing, postage, meeting expenses, etc. The cost of this last issue alone was over $8100 for printing and mailing. Another rising expense is the Association’s $300 Death Benefit. From the time it started in 2006 to date, the total is $120,700. He reminded everyone that the benefit is only for eligible members who are paid up to date.

Tony spoke of the ongoing Medicare Advantage fight with the City of NY. He and President Valentino went to Albany with many other city employee retirees to get the support of the legislators to back the bills that would guarantee our current health benefits. Bob spoke to the crowd along with Marianne Pizzitola of The Organization of Public Service Retirees. Her organization is constantly seeking donations to keep the legal fight going. We ask for the members to send any donation amount to them by going to their website for instructions: www.nycretirees.org

Our Legislative Director, Tony Piazza, couldn’t make the meeting, so 1st VP Deo Fasolino spoke of the current status of the VSF. At the present time, there is a bill in the Assembly – A7824 – but it needs a companion Senate bill to have the VSF benefits extended to those eligible service retirees before July 1, 1987. At present, Tony Piazza estimates about 280 eligible retirees are in that group. We ask that all residents of NY City, their relatives, and friends, send letters to Mayor Adams and their respective NY City Council members and urge them to support the bills that would correct this injustice.

Deo further informed our members that President Valentino bowled his 17th “Perfect 300” game recently. Then Bobby corrected Deo….it was his 70th sanctioned “300” game. Well done, Bobby!

With that, the meeting was adjourned, and we all ventured out to the highways and headed home.

2^nd VP Ron DiMaio and recording Sec’ty Bob Forrester were excused. Many thanks to Financial Sec’ty Greg Stripp and Tom Greer for their help at the door.

Fraternally,

Tony Lomanto

 
L - R   Bob Valentino, Paul Bauer, Mike Sweeney, Bill Frawley                L - Ben Patton, R - Barricinia Thompson, C- Her son, Jordan 

L side top - Steve Mona, Frank Crisa, Tony Lomanto / R side top - Fred Ametrano, Bob Valentino, Al Ciprello
doing a Re-Con assignment for a Brooklyn restaurant on Thursday, May 2nd.

                                   Tony & Bobby in front of the State Capital Building                   Bob talking to the group

                                           Tony Lomanto, Mariann Pizzitola, Bob Valentino                              

Bobby and Tony went by bus to Albany on Monday, the 15th with the Organization of Public Service Retirees to join many other public employee retirees to call on the NY State Senate & State Assembly to pass S8388 / A7866 that would protect the health benefits or contributions of retired employees of public employers.
In asdditon to Marianne Pizzitola and several Senators and Assembly persons. Bobby Valentino spoke to those present about how we were promised certain health benefits and pensions that the City is looking to change.

He ended his talk with "Promises made must be promises kept!"

After his shorrt speech, many of the retirees congratulated Bob on what he said...well put together and well spoken despite the fact the microphone on the lectern was not working.

Thanks to Lou Hollander, those who made speeches can be read HERE

President Valentino and Treasurer Tony Lomanto are planning to go to Albany with the Organization of Public Service Retirees on Monday, April 15th, for the hearing on the bill to protect our retiree health benefits.

Senate Bill S8388A protects the health insurance benefits of retirees of public employers and contributions of retirees of public employers.

Click on the link https://x.com/NYCPDDEA/status/1771160982502408593?s=20

March 11, 2024                                             REPORT OF MARCH MEMBERSHIP MEETING
 

NYPD Transit Bureau Chief Michael Kemper, Michael Sapraicone, NYPD DEA President Paul DiGiacomo

Minutes of the NYCTPOA meeting on Wednesday, March 6, 2024, at Verdi's of Westbury.

The meeting was called to order by President Bob Valentino at 12:30 with the Pledge of Allegiance.

Since our last meeting we lost 19 fellow Transit Police Officers.  A Moment of Silence and prayers were requested for their families and for our members who are sick and for all law enforcement, both active and deceased, and for our Armed Forces serving in harm's way.

We had three guest speakers:

Michael Kemper, Chief of the NYPD Transit Bureau who spoke about his background with the NYPD.  He became Chief of the Transit Bureau 15 months ago.  He spoke sincerely at length about the challenges in the subway; some of the biggest being recidivism and fare evasion with no consequences.  He then answered many questions from the members.

Paul DiGiacomo, President of the NYPD DEA, was the second speaker who shared his memories of 40 years of service starting with the Housing PD. He spoke at length of his love for the Transit Police with his father, Paul Sr. who worked in District 34. He mentioned that he will no longer run for President as his length of service is coming to an end.

The third speaker was Mike Sapraicone. a retired NYPD detective who started in Transit and is a member of this association. Mike is running for the U.S. Senate to replace Kirsten Gillebrand. He mentioned that the current Administration has no plan, and we can change things and the way we live by voting.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported we have 10 new members joining, amongst them is the former Chief of the Transit Police and former NYPD Commissioner, William Bratton, who joined as an Honorary Member at the request of President Valentino. Tony also gave a report on the financials and donations.

He then reported the newest issue of "Beyond The Line" magazine, completed with the expertise of our Esteemed Editor, Frank Crisa, affectionately known as "Merlin the Magician," is now at the printer.  It is the largest issue ever - 56 pages, with donations alone covering 3 pages.  We should get it printed and mailed out by the end of the month. If you don't receive your copy by mid-April, please contact any board member.

If a member has a new mailing or email address, please notify Tony Lomanto to make sure you will receive this issue. As a reminder, it only goes to PAID members, so if you haven't sent in your dues, please do so very soon. This type of mail does NOT get forwarded, so make sure we have your proper mailing address, especially those who are "Snowbirds."

When you receive any emails from the association, please inform your fellow retirees who do not have computer access of the information sent.  If you know of a fellow Transit retiree who is not a member, especially those in the later years of the Transit Police Department, please urge them to join to keep this organization going into the future.

1st VP Deo Fasolino spoke about our departed members, especially Floyd Holloway and Joe Carney, and their contributions to the members of the Transit Police Department, and for Floyd, several other law enforcment members as well.

The City is appealing the recent decision regarding our health insurance co-pays for Emblem Health / GHI members.  The City is trying to "bleed" the organization dry with legal expenses. Donations can be made to the NYCOPSR, c/o JSH Accounting Services, POB 143538, Fayetteville, GA 30214.  Any amount would be helpful.

On June 14, 2024, The Police Retiree's Bowling League will hold their Annual Dinner Dance at Verdi's.  The cost is $140.00 per couple.  Entertainment will be by the group "Desert Highway," the Eagles tribute band.

Please contact Bob Valentino for tickets at leftybowler0601@gmail.com

Bob introduced Ret. Det. Sgt. Fred Ametrano as the new Advisor to the President. Fred has been helpful in the past and we look forward to his help in the association business.

Bob also mentioned that our member, Ret. Sgt. and former Deputy Commissioner Bob Ganley, was appointed to the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees as Vice President. We wish him much success in the organization.

2nd VP Ronnie Di Maio mentioned the 9:30 AM Blue Mass and Communion Breakfast on April 21st in Oceanside NY by the Knights of Columbus at the request of member Ret. Sgt. Larry Lombardo. This Mass will be for active and retired law enforcement and for those killed in the line of duty. The cost is $15.00. Details are on the Latest News page of our website in the February 13th entry posting..

Executive Sec’ty Tom Greer mentioned that there are 6 tickets left for the Yankee-Mets Game.  Please contact Tom Greer if you are interested at 631-902-8911.

Many thanks to Tom, Financial Sec'ty Greg Stripp, and Sgt-at-Arms Mike Lanning for their help at the door welcoming our attending members.

Our next meeting in May will be held at Verdi’s in Whitestone, Queens, and members will be notified with full details. Check the Meetings and Events  page for full details when posted. 

The Meeting adjourned at 2:40 pm.

Fraternally,
Bob Forrester, Recording Secretary, (with able assistance from member Fran Forrester)

 

For our members who have a membership in the BJs Warehouse Club, we have received the latest information for membership renewals that will end on February 2025. Please check the flyer for complete details.

The flyer can be viewed HERE

It’s time to update the BJ’s Offer for your NYC RTPOA members so here you go!

The old pricing ended on February 2nd 2023, and the NEW offer started on February 5, 2024.  Please note that new memberships are only $20 or $60! All processing is still being directed to the Call Center.

Thank you for partnering with us to offer BJ’s Corporate Membership Discount Program as an exciting benefit to your employees!

To better serve you, all membership enrollments and renewals for your employees will be processed through our BJ’s Partnership Support Center.

The attached flyer includes everything your employees will need to take advantage of their membership benefit. Please include this as an attachment when sending the announcement.

The expiration date of the new offer is February 1, 2025.

Please note, listed on the flyer is your organizations ‘Group Promo Code’. This code is unique to your organization. When any of your employees/members call our Partnership Support Center, they will need to reference this ‘Group Promo Code’ to qualify for the discount.

BJ’s Partnership Support Center details -

Phone #: 800-313-8887
Hours of Operation: Monday-Friday from 9:00 AM - 6:00 PM EST (No weekends.)

When an employee calls in, all they will need is the following information -

• Your Organization’s ‘Group Promo Code’, which is 350718.
• Debit or credit card information
• If a current BJ’s member, a membership ID which can be found on their BJ’s membership card or from within the BJ’s app

Here is the current offer: The membership levels are now Club (formerly Inner Circle) and Club + (formerly Rewards).

NEW MEMBER OFFER: (These new member rates are amazing!)   (plus tax in NY and NJ)

Any employee may OPEN a NEW Club membership at the discounted rate of $20/12 months ($35 savings off the In-Club rate of $55/12 months) or 

may OPEN a NEW Club + membership at the discounted rate of $60/12 months ($50 savings off the In-Club rate of $110/12 months).

Both offers also include one household member card at no charge. (2 cards total on membership.) This applies to NEW members only…previous or existing members are not eligible for new member rates.

EXISTING MEMBER OFFER:   (plus tax in NY and NJ)

This program also enables your employees to EXTEND their existing Club or Club + memberships at the rates below:

The Club renewals are only $50/12 months.

The Club + renewals are only $100/12 months.

With payment, 12 months will be ADDED onto current expiration date of existing members.

Paul DiGiacomo, Jr. son of the late Ret Transit PO Paul DiGiacomo, announced that he will be stepping down as President of the NYPD DEA in June, prior to the new elections. He stated that his retirement date is coming up and were he to run as President again, he would not be able to finish his term of office.

His full PDF message report can be read  HERE

Video https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MUpw7IKpLmY

Medicare Part B 2023 Reimbursement

What is IRMAA?

If your income in 2020 was

less than or equal to $91,000 as an individual, or
less than or equal to $182,000 as a married couple,
you did not pay IRMAA in 2022 and the following information does not apply to you.

If your 2022 SSA-1099 form shows that you received the standard Medicare Part B premiums deductions of $2,041.20, you did not pay IRMAA in 2022 and the following information does not apply to you.

Please do NOT submit an IRMAA application as you are not eligible for reimbursement.

IRMAA 2023 Reimbursement

IRMAA 2023 annual reimbursements will be issued during the 3rd week of October 2024. 

IMPORTANT: Please do NOT submit the IRMAA Reimbursement Application for 2023 prior to May 2024.  Processing of these applications will not begin before that date

IRMAA 2022 Reimbursement

IRMAA 2022 annual reimbursements were issued during the 3rd week of October 2023.
Medicare-eligible retirees and their Medicare-eligible dependents can submit an IRMAA application if they paid above the standard amount of $170.10 per month. If you did not pay more than the standard amount then you are not eligible for IRMAA. 

Lou Hollander did a great job with these photos and thanks for sending them out.

The NY Reunion, so well set up by members Marilyn Scahill and Paul Murphy, can be viewed HERE

The Spring Hill R.O.M.E.O. Luncheon, set up by Lou Hollander can be viewed HERE

Thanks to Alan Berkowitz for sending tbis out. berky4@aol.com

Former NYPD DEA President Tom Scotto gives a perfect explanation of what transpired between the City of New York and the Muncipal Labor Council (MLC) regarding the Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan. It's a You Tube video with
Maryann Pizzotola of the Organization of Publice Service Retirees. It's around 20 minutes long but it clarifies many questions.

Watch it here:  https://youtu.be/O9xGAx8aS3k?si=_Yz9sWEFg3RGaK8d

WHAT IT MEANS TO BE A TRANSIT COP

On Thursday November 2nd, we buried (Ret. P.O.) Michael Whalen, but that’s not the story. Among the people who attended his sendoff was Dan Desario (Lifetime Member Ret. P.O.). I never met Dan before. He was a Brooklyn cop that worked in Districts 30 and 33. Dan never worked with Mike and did not know him. Dan drove up from Brentwood, Long Island to Saugerties, New York in his words: “To honor Mike." I was a little preoccupied, so I didn’t get a chance to speak to him much, but when I got home I thought about it. This man, who didn’t know any of us, drove up from Long Island to pay respects to Mike. Dan Desario shows why we are different from everyone else and makes me proud to say: "I was a Transit Cop!"
Thank you Dan.
Well said, Jimmy.

DETECTIVE STEVEN MCDONALD MEMORIAL SCHOLARSHIP

The 2023 Scholarship application process is now open. All completed entries are due no later than Friday February 2, 2024.

Download the application HERE

We were told this is open to all fellow Transit officers who may not have actually retired from NYPD.

November is the month for the annual Fall Transfer Period for Retirees when you can choose to change your current health plan for another. The new plan will go into effect January 1, 2024.

Go to the Office of Labor Relations / Health Benefits website for the proper forms: health-retiree-responsibilities (nyc.gov)

To view the various plan benefits, go to the website: health-sbc (nyc.gov)

A few NYC resident members were asking about their carry permits and the revised NYC regulations when renewing your permit. We are showing this information below.

INFORMATION FOR RETIREES LIVING IN NYC WITH CONCEALED CARRY PERMITS

NYC CC PERMITSFOR NYC RETIREES LIVING IN NYC 5 BOROUGHS ONLY FROM THE LBA BREAKFAST MEETING JANUARY 2023

THIS SHOULD ANSWER ALL THOSE QUESTIONS I HAVE BEEN GETTING.
IF YOU ARE NOT DUE TO RENEW I SUGGEST YOU PRINT THIS OUT AND KEEP IT

NEW TRAINING REQUIREMENTS FOR SOME RETIREES RESIDING IN NYC TO RETAIN CONCEALED CARRY PERMIT: We would like to acknowledge and thank Marty Browne (Retired Sergeant) and Director Nicole Berkovich, from the NYPD License Division, for coming to the LBA meeting to answer questions from the membership regarding the new requirement mandating that some retirees attend a sixteen (16) hour Gun Safety Course and a two (2) hour Live Ammunition Firing Course to renew their Concealed Carry Weapon (CCW) permit issued by the New York City Police Department. This requirement, as of now, only applies to those retirees whose licenses are issued via the NYPD License Division. The different requirements apply in the following three (3) unique scenarios:

Retirees Who Retired Prior To September 1, 2017:

For those retirees who separated from service prior to September 1, 2017, and who receive their Concealed Carry Weapon (CCW) permit from the NYPD License Division, must satisfy the following requirements to successfully renew their permit:
- Attend a sixteen (16) hour Gun Safety Course and a two (2) hour Live Ammo Shooting Course – This is currently a once in a lifetime attendance requirement. OR - Possess proof of attending at least one HR 218 course (ID Card) between the periods of September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022. OR - Proof of having attended any other Gun Safety related course during the periods of September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022. (check with pistol license of the course is acceptable)

Retirees who retired between September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022: As per the stipulations spelled out in the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, retirees who separated from service during this time period are NOT required to provide any additional proof (training or HR 218) to renew their Concealed Carry Weapon Permit.

Retirees who retired on or after September 1, 2022: If they were employed/Active between September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022, are NOT required to provide any additional proof (training or HR 218) to renew their Concealed Carry Weapon Permit.

If a retired member who resides in New York City and who receives their Concealed Carry Weapon permit from the NYPD License Division does not satisfy the renewal mandates stipulated above, the likely results are as follows:
IF RETIREE POSSESSES A: Retired ID Card, Expired Concealed Carry Permit, Does NOT Have a Valid HR 218 = License Division will eventually attempt to confiscate and safeguard your weapons. License Division will usually allow approximately six (6) months after the members current permit expires for member to renew application for Concealed Carry permit.
Retired ID Card, Expired Concealed Carry Permit, VALID HR 218 = Allowed to retain and carry weapon(s). However, will be unable to purchase ammunition and buy/sell gun(s) in New York State. The License Division may eventually contact you to ascertain if you wish to renew Carry or convert to Premise Permit.
Retired ID Card, Expired Concealed Carry Permit, Valid HR 218, Valid Premise Permit: Allowed to retain and carry weapon(s). Premise Permit also allows you to purchase ammunition and to buy/sell gun(s) in New York State.
**Please note that a valid HR 218 is a key requirement in retaining and carrying your weapon when you do not satisfy the CCW renewal requirements and therefore do not have a CCW Permit issued by the NYPD License Division.**
Routinely, retired members will receive a mailed notice from the NYPD License Division, three (3) months prior to their current CCW Permit expiring advising them how to apply for their renewal and what requirements are mandated to successfully renew their CCW. If a member switches from a Concealed Carry Weapon Permit to a Premise Permit, the member may switch back to a CCW permit if they can now satisfy the requirements. However, this conversion cannot take place until the next scheduled permit renewal date (usually three years).
If you are a retiree who receives your CCW Permit from the NYPD License Division and have additional question regarding this matter, please contact 646-610-5872.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IT WAS ASKED ABOUT OTHER COUNTIES OUTSIDE NYC WHO ARE NOT AS STRICT WITH THESE RULES FOR RETIRED NYPD COPS LIVING THERE AND RENEWING.
THE REPLY WAS THAT THOSE OTHER COUNTIES "ARE NOT OBEYING THE NEW LAW"

Because of ever increasing legal fees incurred in this fight, we again urge our members to make a small donation to the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees, P.O. Box 941, Venice, Fl. 34284.  They work very hard and are our hope to keep winning.  Donations can be made by Check, Zelle, PayPal and Venmo. Check details on their website www.nycretirees.org 

Thanks to Alan Berkowitz for spreading the good news. berky4@aol.com

Social Security cost-of-living adjustment adds $50 a month on average

You should be receiving a letter from Social Security next month detailing what your montly payments will be starting in January, 2024. If you come under the IRMAA rules regarding extra cost for Medicare based on your annual income and you file a reimbursement request with OLR, make sure you keep that letter as proof.

For 2024, along with the 3.2 % COLA increase in your monthly Social Security check comes an increase in the monthly Medicare charges of an additional $9.80 to $174.70 and a $14 increase in the annual deductible to $240.00. The Government gives then takes away.

PENSION COLA ADJUSTMENT

By now, you should have received a letter from NYCERS that the anual Cost Of Living Adjustment (COLA) has been increased by 2.5% on the Annual Maximum Retirement Allowance (AMRA) of $18,000. This equates to $37.50 a month which you will receive with the September payment.

Minutes of the NYCTPOA Meeting held on Wednesday, Sept. 6, 2023 from Recording Secretary Bob Forrester and his able assistant, his lovely wife, Fran.

The meeting was called to order by President Bob Valentino at 1:15 pm with the Pledge of Allegiance to The Flag and a moment of silence for the sick and departed. We had over 60 members attend this meeting.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported that since our last meeting we have lost 16 fellow retirees. They were 14 Police Officers and 2 Honorary members.  He asked us to pray for our sick members, especially Mike Lanning who is receiving precautionary chemo treatments and for family members who have passed away. Please check our Sick List page for current information.

Not mentioned at the time was our Editor Frank Crisa is going into the hospital on Friday. September 8^th for a cardiac procedure to regulate his heart rhythm. We pray and wish him well.

 
President Valentino advised us that the COLA increase this year of $37.50 a month will be starting with the September pension deposit.  Payment of the 2022 IRMAA (if applicable to those who paid more each month for Medicare in your Social Security check) will be made the third week in October. If you haven’t filed for it, you can do so and go back 3 years.
Go to the Office of Labor Relations website: health-retiree-medb-irmaa (nyc.gov) 

Bob announced that we are celebrating birthdays to these three members present at the meeting - Emily Sicoli, John White, and Sam Sapienza. Happy Birthday to them and to all our members with September birthdays

Because of ever increasing legal fees incurred in this fight, we urge our members to make a small donation to the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees, P.O. Box 941, Venice, Fl. 34284.  They work very hard and are our hope to keep winning.  Donations can be made by Check, Zelle, PayPal and Venmo. Check details on their website www.nycretirees.org

New York City residents are urged to contact their NY City Council members to protect the NYS Retirees and dependents by supporting legislation that will be introduced in the City Council. It is called INTRO 1099 and will allow Medicare eligible retirees and their eligible Medicare dependents to remain in Medicare and have a Medigap plan with benefits equivalent to or better than those available to City retirees and dependents as of December 31, 2021. Right now they have 17 sponsors but need 34. Go to the Retirees Organization to see who your representative is with contact information.

The NY Reunion will take place this year on Tuesday, November 14^th from 4-8PM at Antuns in Queens Village. The cost is $65 per person by mail or $70 at the door. Payments should be made out to Paul Murphy and mailed to him at 190 Floral Parkway, Floral Park NY 11001. Information is also posted on the Retirees website.

President Valentino reports that Association Treasurer Tony Lomanto will be honored at this year's Christmas Party on Wednesday, December 6th at Verdi's.  Tony has devoted 37 years of service to the organization.

The date and location of the next FOP meeting will be posted on our website when finalized.

Bob urged members living in Queens to vote for George Grasso for Queens County DA.  He is a retired NYPD Chief and has worked in their Legal Department for many years. On Long Island, Association member Mike Sapraicone is running for office to replace George Santos.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto gave the financial report. We have sufficient funds in our checking and have received, since our last newsletter was sent out, over $5,100 in donations and have paid out $115,000 in death benefits since it was started in 2002. Tony also reported we have 19 new members joining since March.

He further reports that we are winning our health insurance battle, but the City is appealing our win.  The City is appealing Judge Frank’s ruling on the Permanent Injunctions to stop the City from moving Medicare retirees into the Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan. Besides that, GHI/Emblem Health is appealing Judge Frank’s ruling about no co-pays with GHI.

Frank Crisa and Tony are working on the next issue of “Beyond The Line” and they expect it will be out by early October. If you have any photos or articles you would like to see in future issues, please send them to Frank Crisa at fcrisa2886@gmail.com or Tony Lomanto at alomanto@optonline.net

Henry Melchiona was thankad for making a plaque of shields of police officers who gave their lives and for bringing it to all the meetings.

Executive Secretary Tom Greer reported the Mets-Yankees games went well this year and we will do it again in 2024. Prices are not known at this time, but probably will go up. The seats should be in the same location as this year or closer. More details to come out as Tom gets information from the Mets Organization.

Legislative Director Tony Piazza reported on VSF bills presented in the Spring. At this time, only about 300 members remain eligible for the VSF. It appears Police oriented bills don’t get favorable attention.

1^st VP Deo Fasolino gave suggestions on how to recruit new members using the various social media platforms and informing fellow retirees who are not members.

Member Joe Asti, who was assigned to the Firearms Range in Transit and NYPD, urged members to make sure their pistol permits are in order.  If they expire and you do not have the HR 218 permit, you will be required to take the 18 hours firearms course and it will take a long time to have them reissued.  Also background checks will be required if you buy ammo after September 13th.

If you have a new email or have moved, please contact Tony Lomanto with the new information to update our records.

Bob Valentino urged members to visit the Retirees Website at least once a week to keep up to date. It is www.beyondtheline-tpa.org

After a delicious meal, President Valentino adjourned the meeting at 2:40 pm. On a side note, we changed the meeting menu from pizza to a full course meal and it appears everyone was well satisfied with this. We will continue this practice at future meetings here at Spuntinos.

Respectfully submitted,

Bob Forrester

A few photos taken at the meeting:
        
President Valentino addressing the membership              Our Official Greeters, Tom Greer and Greg Stripp

      
                                                   Good friends enjoying good company and good food

From the Organization of Public Service Retirees https://www.nycretirees.org

Judge Frank rules in our favor in a short decision which is attached. He bases it on the promise made to us and on the provisions of Admin. Code Section 12-126.

You can read the PDF of Judge Frank's decision HERE

In short, they won the case and you remain in your current plan. The City cannot move you into the Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan.

From the Organization of Public Service Retirees https://www.nycretirees.org

The parties in our most recent case in front of Judge Frank (the attempt to offer only Advantage plans to Medicare retirees) have agreed to request that he issue a decision in the case without further submissions from the parties. (while stipulating that some previously-submitted documents will be included in the record).
This means that the City will not appeal the preliminary injunction granted on July 7 and that both parties will wait for a decision in the case from Judge Frank.  

Below is the link to the letter to Judge Frank and the attachment outlining the previously-submitted documents. Please look at. numbers 99 and 100: 
https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/ViewDocument?docIndex=1j624zh88boFXBUbyYK2TQ==

Here's an interesting article about the Organization of Public Service Retirees at a ‘Save Medicare’ rally in Washington DC. The full article can be read here:

https://www.work-bites.com/view-all/dc-welcomes-nyc-retirees-as-heroes-in-the-fight-to-save-medicare

We received information from Rose Amengual, Assistant Deputy Director, Administration Employee Benefits Program, in response to inquiries we received from surviving spouses who passed away and selected the COBRA benefits from the City of New York health plan.

"Please advise all surviving spouses on COBRA that the judge’s ruling has halted the move to Aetna for them, as well."

This means they will continue in the current plan they now have.

From the Organization of Public Service Retirees www.nycretirees.org

The City has filed a notice of appeal in our most recent case. The link is below. We have no idea how long it will take to have the appeal heard by the Appellate Division:

https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/ViewDocument?docIndex=dfZ8lpe_PLUS_DwVNjs1cGPwaZQ==

Let's hope the City's failure rate continues in this case.

To all our members:

We are very happy to announce that Judge Lyle Frank has granted a Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) against NYC to stop the implementation of the Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan that would have started September 1st.

From the Retired Sergeants Association:

As reported, an “Interim Order on Motion” (Motion 001) was made for “Injunction/Restraining Order” regarding the Aetna MA plan.  Yesterday, July 6^th, Hon. Lyle E. Frank came down with a “Decision & Order On Motion”.  He stated that “the petitioners’ application for a preliminary injunction is granted”.

He goes on to say, “the Court finds that the petitioners have shown by clear and convincing evidence that there is a likelihood of success on the merits. The Court agrees that it is likely that this Court will ultimately find that the respondents are estopped from switching retirees into a Medicare Advantage Plan and that New York City Administrative Code section 12-126 does not permit the action that the City plans to take. Moreover, the Court also feels that some of the petitioners are likely to succeed on the merits based on the “Moratorium Law” and that there is too much uncertainty as to what doctors and other medical providers will accept the proposed new plan, this rendering the plan arbitrary and capricious as things presently stand.”

So, this means is that the Aetna MA plan is on hold and will not be implemented on September 1^st.  We are sure that the City will appeal Hon. Frank’s decision. However, based on the strong words used by Hon. Frank’s “Decision & Order On Motion” we believe that this Temporary Restraining Order (TRO) will stand.

We are awaiting the City’s next move and more importantly Aetna’s next move.  It is possible that Aetna may withdraw.

The full Judge's decision can be read here:
https://iapps.courts.state.ny.us/nyscef/ViewDocument?docIndex=AP/FOvxASbEUkuDjB8jy2g==

From the Organization of Public Service Retirees:

WE WON THE TRO!!!

DO NOTHING!    SEND IN NO FORMS!   MAKE NO CALLS TO OPT OUT!   EVERYTHING STOPS!

IF YOU ALREADY GOT YOURSELF INTO A PLAN FOR SEPTEMBER 1, YOU NEED TO CALL AND FIND OUT HOW TO PAUSE IT OR WITHDRAW.

IF YOU ALREADY FILED YOUR WAIVER, NOTHING HAPPENS.  YOUR CURRENT PLANS STAY IN PLACE!

SUSCRIBE TO THEIR EMAIL LIST TO RECEIVE THEIR NEWSLETTER & IMPORTANT UPDATES:
Click here to Subscribe 

We now have THREE full court cases running, so please make a donation and get your friends to do so too, especially those who doubted us!  

We won EVERY TIME SO FAR!!

Make Your Check or Money Order payable to: 

NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees

Mail to:

NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees
c/o JSH Accounting Services, LLC      

PO Box 143538      

Fayetteville, GA 30214

https://vimeo.com/843243697/8794090307?share=copy

The meeting called to order by President Bob Valentino at 12:15 pm with the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag and a moment of silence for departed and sick members.  Since our last meeting we lost 4 members.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported 14 members still did not pay dues.  12 members were removed after no response to numerous emails and phone calls where necessary. We have received many donations that are still coming in.

Regarding our health care issues, the City is filing on June 16th and our law firm will file on June 20th.  We should know something before June 30th.  There is a rally scheduled for June 20th at which time a bill is scheduled to be introduced at the City Council to have the GHI/Senior Care plan remain in effect. All the information is on our website.

Executive Secretary Tom Greer was congratulated on his promotion to Sergeant in the Nassau PD. He is assigned to the 7th Pct., NCPD.  We also celebrated several birthdays and anniversaries, in particular, Fran and Bob Forrester on their 60th.

Bob Valentino reported there are still some rooms available for the Florida Reunion on July 24th to the 26th.

Bob Valentino was honored at City Field on June 3rd and will be honored on June 30th at Yankee Stadium as Vetran of The Game.  Tickets to games at Citifield can cost $285.00, but Bob can get tickets for $100.00.

Bob mentioned he bowled a 300 game on Tuesday, June 8th. Congratulations, Mr. President!

Member Joe Asti gave a very informative summary on Concealed Carry Permits for members living in New York and Nassau County.  For example, in Nassau County there is an HR218 class given by Safety Quest at SafetyQuestLtd.com or call 631-876-5438.
  
Bob wished everyone a good summer and urged the members to visit the website often for updates.

The next meeting will be held at Spuntino's on September 6th at 12:00 pm, and the meeting wasa adjourned at 1:50 pm.

Respectfully submitted, Bob Forrester (with able assistance from his wife, Fran)

This is the latest information form the Organization of Public Service Retirees NYCorgOfPublicServiceRetirees@gmail.com
 

Comptroller Lander Declines to Register Medicare Advantage Contract Pending Litigation 
 

New York, NY – The Comptroller’s Office declined to register the City’s contract with Aetna to transfer City retirees to a Medicare Advantage program for their health care coverage. A pending lawsuit, brought on behalf of retirees, questions the City’s authority to enter into such an agreement. 

Comptroller Brad Lander issued the following statement:

“The Comptroller’s Bureau of Contract Administration carefully reviewed the City’s contract with Aetna and returned the contract to the Office of Labor Relations without registering it. Pending litigation calls into question the legality of this procurement and constrains us from fulfilling our Charter mandated responsibility to confirm that procurement rules were followed, sufficient funds are available, and the City has the necessary authority to enter into the contract.

“As a matter of public policy, beyond the scope of our office’s specific Charter responsibility for contract registration, I am seriously concerned about the privatization of Medicare plans, overbilling by insurance companies, and barriers to care under Medicare Advantage. 
“I appreciate the work of the Municipal Labor Council and the Office of Labor Relations to negotiate improvements to the Aetna contract to address some of the concerns raised by retirees. However, the broader Medicare Advantage trends are worrisome. Recent investigations identified extensive allegations of fraud, abuse, overbilling, and denials of medically necessary care at 9 of the top 10 Medicare Advantage plans, including CVS Health, which owns Aetna. 

“As health care activist Ady Barkan wrote last month, noting that half of Medicare enrollees nationwide have been transferred from traditional Medicare to private Medicare Advantage plans: ‘Once corporations privatize every inch of the public provision of health care, we may never get Medicare back.’”

This article also appeared in The Dialy News today and this item was added:

Lander’s Advantage move may end up being mostly symbolic, as the Charter gives a mayor the power to override a comptroller’s contract rejection.

From the Organization of Public Service Retirees:

As we said yesterday, we CANCELLED the rally for today, June 8th. The air quality is very bad and we are very concerned for your health and safety. We have been advised that the legislation WILL NOT be introduced from the Council Stated Meeting as to keep Councilman Barron safe too!  We WILL RESCHEDULE THE RALLY for EITHER JUNE 20 or 22.  STAY TUNED!

This was sent out yesterday, June 7th, by the Organization:

Justice Lyle E. Frank, the same judge who decided our first two cases (and who was upheld unanimously twice by the Appellate Division!) will be handling our current case. That is good news!

We have learned that he has set a briefing schedule for the case: the City will file its responsive papers on Friday, June 16 and our lawyers will file our reply papers on Tuesday, June 20. Soon after, there will be oral argument, which retirees may attend.

For those of you who are worried about this: the judge will definitely issue a decision before the June 30 deadline to opt out or waive our City health insurance: he will either issue an interim order to push back the June 30 deadline or he will rule on the preliminary injunction before June 30. We definitely will know before the June 30 deadline!

So what should you do now? 
If you are planning to waive your City health benefits, don't file the City form just yet. The OLR form is on its website here: 2023-retiree-special-enrollment-form.pdf (nyc.gov)

You can see that you can mail it, fax it, or submit it electronically.

You should investigate your options if you want to remain in traditional Medicare with a Medigap plan, and if you need it, a Part D prescription drug plan. If you live in New York, you have plenty of time to get those plans with an effective date of September 1: I was told that you can apply as late as mid-August, but no need to wait that long, of course. In some other states, you may have to apply for a Medigap plan soon to have it effective on September 1. Find out whether you should start the process now and whether you can withdraw your Medigap application if we win our case. You can apply for a Part D plan online (if you need one) and that does not take very long to do.

Marianne emphasizes that you should check to see whether you can get out of your Medigap plan in the event that you need to sign up for one soon but then don't need it because we win our court case. (At least for the Medigap plan I am likely to take, I can cancel before it takes effect or get out of the Medigap plan easily if our court case drags on and the Medigap plan has already taken effect, and only pay for the months that I was enrolled in it). But check on this!

They are still pushing for Council legislation that would protect our choice of a premium-free Medigap plan. The draft calendar for the Council meeting on Thursday indicates that Council Member Barron will introduce our legislation but it remains to be seen if he actually does it.

For the spouses of a deceased retiree currently taking the COBRA benefits from NYC for their health plans, we inquired as to their standings and were informed of this from the Office of Labor Relations (OLR). That benefit is for life as opposed to the line organization benefits which are only for three (3) years.

This was their response:

Thank you for your correspondence to Commissioner Campion regarding COBRA recipients.

COBRA recipients will go into the Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan, as the current health plans will cease to exist for these individuals as of September 1, 2023.

Please be advised that a communication from Aetna to COBRA recipients regarding the change in health coverage went out last week.

Below is a link to COBRA information, including rates.

https://www.nyc.gov/assets/olr/downloads/pdf/health/cobra-package-january-2023.pdf

https://youtu.be/QLdUL0fczy0

We are very proud to announce the promotion to Sergeant of our Executive Secretary, Tom Greer. Tom will receive his Sergeant stripes on Tuesday, May 30th at the 7th Nassau PD Pct.

Tom was also honored by radio station WBAB as their Friday's First Responder Recipient last week and received a $100 gift card at a Moes Southwest Grill restaurant.

In the celebration story, it was mentioned that Tom followed his father's footsteps (also Tom Greer) and started in the Transit Police in 1986, rolled over to NYPD in '87 then into Nassau PD in '94. He worked in Highway from '98 to the present and hopes he can stay in Highway until he retires.

Well done, Tom! Hearty congratulations and much sucess.

At the NY Black Patch Reunion held on Saturday, May 20th, a number of our members, specifically, Floyd Holloway, along with
Joe Carney from the Transit PBA, Ken Chiulli and Steve Mona from the Vandals Unit, and Hugh Lennon from the Firearms Range Unit, were honored. Unfortunately neither Floyd or Joe were able to attend, but Floyd had a video made of his thanks for the honor.

It can be seen here https://youtu.be/viDlKDGhX8Y

Minutes of the NYCRTPOA on May 3, 2023 held at Spolini's Restaurant, Richmond Hill, Queens, NY.

The meeting was called to order at 12:15 pm by President Bob Valentino with the Pledge of Allegiance to The Flag.
Since the last meeting we lost 14 officers.

Financially, we are doing well and have received many donations since the last donation period ending on March 12th and we have 20 new members.

Bob spoke about the Defensive Driving Course which will be held on Saturday, May 20th, 10:00 am at 51 Atlantic Ave. in Floral Park.  Those interested can contact Robin Becker at tigercat824@verison.net.

Other items discussed were the Bowling Dinner/Dance to be held at Verdi's on June 9th; the NYCTP Florida Reunion July 24th to the 26th at the Radisson Resort, Cape Canaveral, FL and the Black Patch Reunion in Myrtle Beach, Sept. 14-18, 2023.  For more information please see our Website.

Frank Crisa and Tony Lomanto were again congratulated on the great work done on the Beyond The Line magazine.  Frank encouraged members to send stories to him which they would like to share.  He also requested photographs which would be returned to you.

Two Birthdays were celebrated - Frank Crisa and Vinnie Servedio. 

The NYC Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan was discussed with help from Jay Finn of the NY 10-13 Association.  Members were urged to do nothing until we hear from the organization.  Updates will be posted on the Website and by email.

Members were also encouraged to send donations to the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees.  They are litigating very hard on our behalf.  See their Website www.nycretirees.org for more information.

Bob also suggested we visit our Website every week for updated info.

Tom Greer spoke about Bob Valentino, a Military Vet, who will be honored on June 3, 2023, at 4pm (end of the third inning) by the New York Mets at Citi Field for his Vietnam Military Service. It may or may not be televised. Bob was an Army Sergeant and is a Purple Heart Recipient. He also received a Presidential Citation and 50 Year Commemorative Medal.  He served from 1967 to 1968.

Congratulations, Bob, from the Board and members, and thank you for your services.

Tony Piazza gave an update on the VSF.  Our new bill will be presented to the Committee, and we will keep at it.

Bob thanked everyone for coming.  The meeting at this new location was a success, and there was a great turnout.  Members were happy to see those they haven't seen in a long time.

The next meeting will be June 7th at Verdi's in Westbury.

The meeting was adjourned at 3:00 pm.

Respectfully submitted
Bob Forrester, Recording Secretary

Information from the Employees Organization regarding "opting out."

First, do not do anything yet. The organization will let you know when you need to take any action. There is no May 1 “deadline” – even under the current information from OLR, you have until the end of June to “opt out.”

Second, unless you live in the 10 counties which are covered by HIP VIP and want to join that plan, you do not want to “opt out” of Aetna; to do that would mean that you would be put into the HIP VIP plan.
 
If you want to keep traditional Medicare, and we do not prevail in court or at the City Council, you will need to waive your insurance coverage, and must fill out a form to do so. But again, do not do that yet.

If you have any questions, please email NYCOrgofPublicServiceRetirees@gmail.com

Below is the relevant text of the OLR web page: health-retiree-responsibilities (nyc.gov)

On September 1, 2023, the City will discontinue the Senior Care Plan and all other retiree plans except Aetna Medicare Advantage and HIP VIP. All Medicare-eligible retirees and Medicare-eligible dependents, with the exception of HIP VIP members, will be automatically enrolled in the Aetna Medicare Advantage PPO Plan.

HIP VIP members who wish to leave HIP VIP and enroll in the Aetna Medicare Advantage PPO Plan must complete the Health Benefits Program Retiree Special Enrollment/Waiver Form (available May 1, 2023).

Retirees who reside in the HIP VIP service area (Manhattan, Brooklyn, Bronx, Staten Island, Queens, Nassau, Suffolk, Westchester, Rockland and Orange counties) and wish to participate in HIP VIP instead of the Aetna Medicare Advantage plan may do so by contacting Aetna at 1-855-648-0389 or by visiting Aetna's website at CONY.AetnaMedicare.com  and indicating that they wish to "opt out" of Aetna Medicare Advantage PPO Plan.  No opt-out form will be required.  They must contact Aetna between May 1, 2023, and June 30, 2023 in order to do so.

HIP VIP members who wish to remain in the HIP VIP plan do not have to do anything.

Retirees who do not wish to be enrolled in the Aetna Medicare Advantage PPO Plan or HIP VIP can waive City health coverage. Retirees must complete the Health Benefits Program Retiree Special Enrollment/Waiver Form (available May 1, 2023) to waive City coverage. Retirees who waive health coverage are not eligible for Medicare Part B reimbursement.

Contact the Aetna NYC Retiree dedicated call center at 1-855-648-0389 (TTY: 711), Monday to Friday, 8 a.m. to 9 p.m.
Aetna will work with you to resolve any questions about the benefits, the network, or clinical transition questions.

Thanks to Alan Berkowitz berky4@aol.com for sending this out

NEW PROCEDURE FOR TPD ID CARDS

Meeting was called to order by President Bob Valentino with the Pledge of Allegiance to the Flag, followed by a moment of silence for the 18 deceased police officers since the last meeting as well as their families and also for sick members. We mentioned member Jack Rossiter’s grandson, NYPD PO Colin Rossiter, who he lost last week.

Bob mentioned that there is much information on the website and encouraged the members to avail themselves of it.

On May 20^th, there will be a Black Patch Party at Verdi's from 12:30 to 4:00 pm.  Floyd Holloway, Joe Carney, Hugh Lennon and Ken Chiulli will be honored.  There will be a few new members inducted into the Sports Hall of Fame at the affair, but future inductees will only be held at the annual Association Christmas / Holiday Party.

Treasurer Tony Lomanto reported we have $32,139 in checking and so far, we received $18,000 in donations. This helps to offset the increasing number of members attaining Lifetime Membership status as dues are no longer required. Every donation is well appreciated. He also mentioned that 55 members have not yet paid their dues, and they may be removed from membership if not received in the next 2 months..

The cost of publishing the newsletter has gone up along with postage and mailings. The next issue, 2023-1, will be finalized by this coming Sunday, March 12th, and will consist of 48 pages.  Any letters or donations received after that will be in the next issue. Tony and Frank were thanked for all their hard work.

For New York City residents only, information on renewing your carry permits can be found on the website below. Unless you completed an HR218 course before August 31, 2022, you will be forced to take the 16-hour training course and the 2 hours at the firing range. The alternative is a permit but only for your home premises.

The Labor Council is in favor of the new Medical Plan and will be voting on Thursday, March 9th. Members are encouraged to donate to the NYC Organization of Public Service Retirees so that the litigation can continue at PO Box 941, Venice, FL.34284

FOP Lodge #317 will hold a special Memorial Gathering to honor Joe McGarry from 12:00 to 4:00pm on Saturday, April 15th at The Hartigan House, 517 Central Ave., Bethpage, NY. There will be a Chinese Auction. Full details will be posted on the “Meetings and Events” page when finalized and emails will be sent out to Lodge 317 members. All proceeds of the event will go to the Tunnel to Towers Foundation in memory of Joe McGarry.

The next meeting will be held on Wednesday, May 3rd From 12:00 noon to approximately 2:00 PM at Spolini's Restaurant 116-25 Metropolitan Ave. (off Union Turnpike), Richmond Hill. Members asked for another location closer to Brooklyn & Staten Island and this place was found to have a large function room and good food. Attendance at this meeting will determine it as a future location.  Tony and Bob will be sending information on parking and directions.

June 9th there will be a Bowling League Dinner/Dance at Verdi's.  Emil Stucchio and the Classics will be performing.  The cost is $140.00 per couple but could be less depending on the number of people attending.

Last year we had 50 new members join.  This year so far, we have 43 new members. Please advise Tony Lomanto if you have a new email address or have recently moved.

The meeting ended at 2:15 pm.

Bob Forrester

 As mentioned above, the MLC voted today in favor of accepting the proposed Aetna Medicare Advantage Plan. Today, March 9^th, they actually voted in favor of the plan. 79% of the voting unions voted YES and the voting is based on the number of union members. The UFT, DC37 & the Sanitation union have the most votes.

Crane's Business magazine posted this article about the vote. It can be viewed in this PDF

There are also a number of videos on You Tube with Marianne Pizzitola from the NYC Retirees Organization describing the latest events in their fight against the City.

We will post ongoing information here as they develop.

INFORMATION FOR RETIREES LIVING IN NYC WITH CONCEALED CARRY PERMITS

NYC CC PERMITSFOR NYC RETIREES LIVING IN NYC 5 BOROUGHS ONLY FROM THE LBA BREAKFAST MEETING JANUARY 2023

THIS SHOULD ANSWER ALL THOSE QUESTIONS I HAVE BEEN GETTING.
IF YOU ARE NOT DUE TO RENEW I SUGGEST YOU PRINT THIS OUT AND KEEP IT

NEW TRAINING REQUIREMENTS FOR SOME RETIREES RESIDING IN NYC TO RETAIN CONCEALED CARRY PERMIT: We would like to acknowledge and thank Marty Browne (Retired Sergeant) and Director Nicole Berkovich, from the NYPD License Division, for coming to the LBA meeting to answer questions from the membership regarding the new requirement mandating that some retirees attend a sixteen (16) hour Gun Safety Course and a two (2) hour Live Ammunition Firing Course to renew their Concealed Carry Weapon (CCW) permit issued by the New York City Police Department. This requirement, as of now, only applies to those retirees whose licenses are issued via the NYPD License Division. The different requirements apply in the following three (3) unique scenarios:

Retirees Who Retired Prior To September 1, 2017:

For those retirees who separated from service prior to September 1, 2017, and who receive their Concealed Carry Weapon (CCW) permit from the NYPD License Division, must satisfy the following requirements to successfully renew their permit:
- Attend a sixteen (16) hour Gun Safety Course and a two (2) hour Live Ammo Shooting Course – This is currently a once in a lifetime attendance requirement. OR - Possess proof of attending at least one HR 218 course (ID Card) between the periods of September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022. OR - Proof of having attended any other Gun Safety related course during the periods of September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022. (check with pistol license of the course is acceptable)

Retirees who retired between September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022: As per the stipulations spelled out in the New York State Division of Criminal Justice Services, retirees who separated from service during this time period are NOT required to provide any additional proof (training or HR 218) to renew their Concealed Carry Weapon Permit.

Retirees who retired on or after September 1, 2022: If they were employed/Active between September 1, 2017, through August 31, 2022, are NOT required to provide any additional proof (training or HR 218) to renew their Concealed Carry Weapon Permit.

If a retired member who resides in New York City and who receives their Concealed Carry Weapon permit from the NYPD License Division does not satisfy the renewal mandates stipulated above, the likely results are as follows:
IF RETIREE POSSESSES A: Retired ID Card, Expired Concealed Carry Permit, Does NOT Have a Valid HR 218 = License Division will eventually attempt to confiscate and safeguard your weapons. License Division will usually allow approximately six (6) months after the members current permit expires for member to renew application for Concealed Carry permit.
Retired ID Card, Expired Concealed Carry Permit, VALID HR 218 = Allowed to retain and carry weapon(s). However, will be unable to purchase ammunition and buy/sell gun(s) in New York State. The License Division may eventually contact you to ascertain if you wish to renew Carry or convert to Premise Permit.
Retired ID Card, Expired Concealed Carry Permit, Valid HR 218, Valid Premise Permit: Allowed to retain and carry weapon(s). Premise Permit also allows you to purchase ammunition and to buy/sell gun(s) in New York State.
**Please note that a valid HR 218 is a key requirement in retaining and carrying your weapon when you do not satisfy the CCW renewal requirements and therefore do not have a CCW Permit issued by the NYPD License Division.**
Routinely, retired members will receive a mailed notice from the NYPD License Division, three (3) months prior to their current CCW Permit expiring advising them how to apply for their renewal and what requirements are mandated to successfully renew their CCW. If a member switches from a Concealed Carry Weapon Permit to a Premise Permit, the member may switch back to a CCW permit if they can now satisfy the requirements. However, this conversion cannot take place until the next scheduled permit renewal date (usually three years).
If you are a retiree who receives your CCW Permit from the NYPD License Division and have additional question regarding this matter, please contact 646-610-5872.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
IT WAS ASKED ABOUT OTHER COUNTIES OUTSIDE NYC WHO ARE NOT AS STRICT WITH THESE RULES FOR RETIRED NYPD COPS LIVING THERE AND RENEWING.
THE REPLY WAS THAT THOSE OTHER COUNTIES "ARE NOT OBEYING THE NEW LAW"